G20 summit no panacea for free trade – economists

By Xie Jingwei and Li Qian (chinadaily.com.cn)
Updated: 2009-04-02 08:55

The Group of 20 summit in London may only lay a common groundwork for cooperation rather than produce any substantial results in stemming the growing trend of protectionism, as global trade contracts for the first time in six years, experts predict.

Leaders of 20 major developed and developing countries, which account for more than 80 percent of the world economy, are gathering in the British capital for meetings on Thursday to find ways out of the global recession. High on the agenda is protectionism that many believe may deepen and prolong the current crisis.

Special coverage:  G20 Financial Summit Related readings:  'China should fight protectionism'  HSBC chief: China vital to fight on protectionism  Hopes that G20 may limit protectionism  China move to global standards damps protectionism  Veto of Coke bid is not protectionism

Despite an almost global consensus on the harm of protectionist measures, the head of governments and states are unlikely to come out of the meeting rooms with major specific actions except new pledges, experts say.

"It would come as a surprise if any marked progress is made on fighting protectionism during the summit," said Hua Xiaohong, a leading scholar of regional economy at the University of International Business and Economics (UIBE).

The meeting is unlikely to change the current international trade climate, she told chinadaily.com.cn in a telephone interview.

Seventeen of the 20 countries have imposed a variety of protectionist measures since the Washington summit in November when they pledged to keep protectionism at bay, the World Bank said in a report last month.

"Where there is a country, there is protectionism," Hua explained, saying that especially during an economic downturn, national interests rise above everything else.

Zhang Xiaoji of the State Council Development Research Center (DRC), a major government think tank pointed to the defects in the current mechanism for predicting no major developments in fighting against protectionism.

"The G20 doesn’t have decision-making power. All we can expect from the summit is to find common ground and pave the groundwork for cooperation," he said.

Even if the leaders don’t come up with a strategic plan, the summit is still a positive sign, analysts believed.

"It means more than a gathering for another family photo," said Xu Mingqi with the Shanghai Academy of Social Sciences.

"The summit is a sign of international coordination, which is the first step for solving disputes and making progress," said Xu, adding that a cooperative mechanism will be established to reflect on what the world needs in the future.

Thanks to the willingness to cooperate, the increasing integration of the global economy, and growing calls for free trade, the possibility of a large-scale trade war like the one in the 1930s is low.

"The whole world is now in the same boat," said Zhang of the DRC, adding that countries are well aware that trade sanctions and punitive tariffs against foreign companies may ultimately hurt themselves as well.

In addition, the demands for free trade have been rising in the past few decades, and globalization is the trend, Professor Hua of the UIBE said.

 

China Effort

• China raises financial status at G20
• China buys IFC bonds, backs trade finance
• Shopping team headed for US tour
• China, Argentina to push for equitable financial system
• Vice premier calls on G20 to fight crisis unitedly
• more

Global Action

• Chinese, Russian experts discuss super currency
• G20 leaders agree on supervisory body
• G20 summit progress despite differences
• G20 leaders mull tripling of funds available through IMF
• Desperate world leaders meet on economic woes
• more

Related Coverage

• Hu at G20 and APEC
• China Statistics
• 2009 NPC and CPPCC
• Chinese Economy
• World Financial Crisis
• more