Court tries 1973 zoo injury case
By Liu Li (China Daily)
Updated: 2004-06-16 22:14

As a 17-year-old trainee, Liu Shulan was bitten to death by a hippo at the Beijing Zoo.

That was in 1973.

Thirty-one years later, Liu's mother Zhang Yuzhen, 86, is suing the zoo for 440,000 yuan (US$53,000).

"I was paid 700 yuan (US$85) in total in 1973 by the Beijing Municipal Bureau of Parks," Zhang said in her indictment at the Beijing Xicheng District People's Court Wednesday.

She said bureau officials vowed that the victim's family will be paid compensation in the future when there is a State policy or law specifying compensation for students killed by industrial injuries.

Zhang was paid 6,800 yuan (US$820) in three batches between 1998 and 2003, she said.

Her latest lawsuit is based on the General Principles of Civil Law, which went into effect in 1987, and a 2003 judicial interpretation by the Supreme People's Court. The interpretation covers compensation lawsuits for personal injuries in 2003.

Despite testimony from Tian Qingzhu, a former official with the Beijing Municipal Bureau of Parks, that dealt with the accident 31 years ago, bureau officials stuck by their guns.

"Zoo staff never promised to offer more compensation in the future to Liu's family," Xiao Shaoxiang, vice-manager of the zoo, said Wednesday during the first court hearing on the case.

He said the compensation of 700 yuan (US$85) in 1973 was final.

"Although the amount seems small now, salary and price at that time were also much lower," Xiao said.

The zoo also helped the victim's family get a new house and arranged a job for Liu's elder sister in Beijing.

The zoo's consultant Wang Houyan said Liu's accident was caused by her disobeying management rules.

Wang also doubted whether a 31-year-old accident could be the subject of litigation.

"Even if limitation began in 1987 when the General Principles of the Civil Law went into effect, it would end by 1988," he said.

Wang also pointed to Ministry of Education legislation passed in 2002 which says that student injuries already settled cannot be retried.

Close

Today's Top News     Top China News
NBS: China capable of avoiding severe inflation         US bill to help Taiwan join WHO opposed         Former Guizhou Party chief tried for bribery         Oil drilling deal inked with Uzbekistan         US general: I'm told to treat POWS like 'dog'         Bush on Saddam handover: Must stay in jail	PLA general: Attempt to destroy dam doomed       Three Gorges dam to face challenge as rainstorm approaches       Coal mine blast kills 15 in Shaanxi       Premier pledges effective HIV/AIDS control       NBS: China capable of avoiding severe inflation       Report: HK economic recovery becomes sustained