 Mirror, mirror, on the wall, who's the ugliest of us all?
Wall-to-wall mirrors in gyms and dance studios might stop women getting the exercise they need because women who work out in front of a mirror get discouraged and feel tired, Canadian researchers said. The study, published in the journal Health Psychology, focused on young women who exercised less than 15 minutes a week. It found that, regardless of how they viewed their bodies, women who worked out in front of a mirror felt worse, or no better, and less at peace after 20 minutes of activity. "The mirrors make women more self-aware, they think of their shortcomings. Things like: 'I look fat, I should be more active'," said Kathleen Martin Ginis, lead author of the study, and a professor at McMaster University in Hamilton, Ontario. "When women are more introspective, they might feel 'I'm not that great' unfortunately." The survey questioned 58 women with an average age of 22 -- young enough to be concerned about body image. Participants took turns on stationary bicycles, working out either in front of a mirror or with the mirror curtained over. And whether the participant felt comfortable about her body or not, the outcome was the same -- women who did not have to watch themselves exercise felt calmer, more positive and more revitalized at the end of their session. Still, Martin Ginis stressed that mirrors can be positive and functional. "I don't want to convey the idea that we should rip out gym mirrors," she said, noting that exercisers often needed to see their form, or assess if they are using the correct muscles groups during strength training. But things were different for beginners. "For beginner exercisers, mirrors can be daunting," she said. Martin Ginis suggested gyms provide areas without mirrors to encourage novice exercisers. "Women don't need to exercise in a gym," she said. "Thirty minutes of walking, or hiking is good too. There are other ways to get your exercise." (Agencies) | 鏡子啊鏡子，墻上的鏡子，誰(shuí)是我們當(dāng)中最丑的一個(gè)？ 健身房和舞蹈房?jī)?nèi)四周的鏡子可能會(huì)妨礙婦女們得到她們所需要的鍛煉，因?yàn)楫?dāng)她們面對(duì)鏡子鍛煉身體時(shí)，會(huì)感到灰心喪氣，精疲力竭。這是加拿大研究人員作出的結(jié)論。 該論文發(fā)表在《健康心理學(xué)》雜志上，主要研究對(duì)象是每周鍛煉時(shí)間不足15分鐘的婦女。經(jīng)研究發(fā)現(xiàn)，無(wú)論她們?nèi)绾慰创约旱捏w形，在鏡子前進(jìn)行鍛煉的婦女會(huì)感覺(jué)更糟或者不好，鍛煉20分鐘過(guò)后，她們就感覺(jué)不那么心平氣和。 該論文的主要作者凱瑟琳·馬丁·吉尼說(shuō)：“鏡子使女人更有自知之明，讓她們想起自己的短處，比如'我看上去很胖，我應(yīng)該多運(yùn)動(dòng)'。當(dāng)婦女變得更加自省的時(shí)候，她們可能會(huì)很遺憾地認(rèn)為‘我沒(méi)有那么好’。” 馬丁·吉尼是安大略州漢彌頓市麥克馬司特大學(xué)的教授。 此項(xiàng)調(diào)查詢(xún)問(wèn)了58位女性，她們的平均年齡為22歲——正是關(guān)心體形的年紀(jì)。 參加調(diào)查的人輪流在健身腳踏車(chē)上進(jìn)行鍛煉，有的面對(duì)著鏡子，有的則把鏡子掩蓋起來(lái)。 無(wú)論參加者對(duì)她們自己的體形感到滿(mǎn)意與否，結(jié)果都是一樣的——那些不用照鏡子的人在運(yùn)動(dòng)結(jié)束時(shí)更平靜，更自信，更加充滿(mǎn)活力。 盡管如此，馬丁·吉尼強(qiáng)調(diào)說(shuō)鏡子也可以發(fā)揮積極有效的作用。她說(shuō)：“我不是說(shuō)我們應(yīng)該詛咒健身房里的鏡子。”她談到鍛煉者經(jīng)常需要看到自己的形態(tài)，或者在進(jìn)行力量訓(xùn)練時(shí)觀察自己運(yùn)用的肌肉組織是否正確。 但是這對(duì)于初學(xué)者來(lái)說(shuō)就不一樣了。她說(shuō)：“鏡子會(huì)令初學(xué)者感到畏懼。” 馬丁·吉尼建議健身房應(yīng)該提供周?chē)鷽](méi)有鏡子的場(chǎng)地來(lái)鼓勵(lì)新手。 她說(shuō)：“婦女們其實(shí)并不需要在健身房中進(jìn)行鍛煉。散步30分鐘或徒步旅行也不錯(cuò)，鍛煉還有許多其它的方法。” （中國(guó)日?qǐng)?bào)網(wǎng)站譯） |
Updated: 2003-08-06 01:00
