Something's cooking for biofuel gutter oil

Clockwise from top: A police officer in Nantong, Jiangsu province, shows local residents how to distinguish gutter oil from the genuine article. The classes are part of a September campaign in the city to reduce the use of recycled gutter oil in public eateries. A worker processes gutter oil into biodiesel at the factory of Jiangsu Clean Environmental Technology Co Ltd in Suzhou. The company is one of only a handful in China that are allowed to recycle the waste into fuel. Zhao Feng collecting swill from a restaurant in Suzhou. Zhao and his father Zhao Jinghua can earn a combined 10,000 yuan a month by collecting gutter oil and waste from 100 restaurants in the city every day. All the waste oil they collect is transported to Jiangsu Clean to be processed into biodiesel. Xie Yu / China Daily

Waste liquid has energy use but process faces hurdles, Xie Yu and Wang Hongyi report in Shanghai.

The smell from Zhao Feng's van is so disgusting that anyone sitting in the cab for five minutes begins to feel nauseous.

And that is not the worst, according to the 26-year-old former courier. "In the summer the smell is so strong that even people passing by cannot stand it."

But Zhao has to bear the odor, because that is part of his current job.

From time to time, he jumped down from the wagon and rushed off, returning with a number of dirty buckets filled with kitchen refuse and food waste blended with water and oil. It's a mixture that's often used to feed pigs in China.

From 7:00 am to 11:00 pm, Zhao and his father, 48-year-old Zhao Jinghua, a former farmer, drive around Suzhou in East China's Jiangsu province to collect kitchen rubbish from more than 100 restaurants.

Zhao Feng got this job more than a year ago. The work is much more tiring than delivering packages, but it pays much more, which is vital in helping to support his wife and two children. After Zhao had spent six months collecting waste, his father decided to join him.

In a good month as a mail courier, Zhao could earn more than 2,000 yuan ($317). His father used to make 2,000 yuan a year, growing peanuts and corn in their home province of Shandong. However, their new line of work means they can now earn a combined 10,000 yuan a month.

Moreover, both father and son believe they are performing a valuable service on behalf of the city. They are taking care of gutter oil, the discarded cooking material that clogs the city's sewers and can be seen glistening on the surfaces of the pools standing outside restaurants and other eateries.

Toxic product

After a simple procedure, the gutter oil is reclaimed as cooking oil and sold at a price of 11,000 yuan a ton. However, the reclaimed oil is toxic. After being reheated too many times, it begins to produce harmful substances such as fats, trans-fatty acids and even carcinogens. It is also a breeding ground for bacteria. However, it is difficult to distinguish the genuine article from gutter oil once it has undergone the reclamation process.

China was shocked last year when the media began to report on how the estimated 2 to 3 million tons of waste cooking oil produced every year is recycled and reused in restaurants, hotels and public canteens.

On Monday, the Ministry of Public Security in Beijing said a recent three-month national campaign against gutter oil had destroyed 60 criminal production networks, spanning 28 provinces. These networks usually comprise a number of links, including collection, rough filtering, advanced processing and sales. More than 700 suspects and 60,000 tons of recycled oil were seized during the operation.

Production chain

Despite this, the ministry said that it had found no evidence of major production or sales of gutter oil, and that it had only discovered a small number of illegal workshops, which, it said, indicated that the safety of cooking oil has improved.

However, it seems more likely that the production chain of reclaimed gutter oil is widespread and that the specter of toxic cooking oil will keep haunting the public.

Meanwhile in Suzhou, Zhao Feng and Zhao Jinghua, and their 200-plus colleagues are exploring the possibility of turning the waste oil into precious energy.

The workers in Suzhou collect approximately 290 tons of kitchen waste and gutter oil every day. It's sent to a processing plant in a nearby suburb, owned by a company called Jiangsu Clean Environmental Technology Co Ltd. There, the oil is broken down into marsh gas and biodiesel fuel, which can be used to run automobiles and airplanes.

The fuel is sold for about 8,000 yuan a ton. After costs, the company can make a profit of between 500 and 800 yuan from each ton of used oil, according to Song Kaibo, the manager, who added that the plant can produce 30 tons of biodiesel fuel a day when working at full capacity.

It seems a profitable business, but, of course, there's a snag. Song said his company is the "only one" that can survive and maintain a "slender profit" in China because of a "problem rooted in the raw materials".

"The production of biodiesel fuel is a high-tech industry, which requires high investment. That means we cannot afford expensive raw materials," he explained.

As the only authorized collector of kitchen waste in Suzhou, Jiangsu Clean doesn't have to spend a penny on collecting the used oil. According to the municipal regulations, restaurants and other outlets are legally obliged to give their kitchen waste to the company, and it is illegal to supply kitchen waste of any kind to other collectors.

However, in other places biodiesel fuel producers are not so lucky. In Shanghai, Zhongqi Environmental Protection Co Ltd and Luming Environmental Protection Co Ltd are the only companies authorized to dispose of waste oil. However, a lack of raw materials means that both of them are engaged in a desperate struggle for survival.

"Our factory can produce up to 40 tons of biodiesel fuel every day, but currently we are only producing nine or 10 tons. We only work two days a week and the number of employees has shrunk by 50 percent," Xu Zhenye, the deputy general manager of Shanghai Zhongqi Environmental Protection, told SMG Radio.

Luming Environmental Protection, Xu's rival, is facing a similar predicament. "We receive less than 20 tons of raw material on a daily basis, which makes it hard to maintain normal operations," said a Luming staff member, who declined to give his name.

Shanghai is home to approximately 40,000 restaurants. The city has licensed more than 20 companies with 450 workers to collect and transport waste oil to the premises of Shanghai Zhongqi Environmental Protection and Shanghai Luming Environmental Protection. However, the companies only receive around 30 percent of the total waste produced in the city every day.

Insiders have no doubt that the missing oil is sent for illegal further processing and is then reused in restaurants, but the collection companies denied the allegations.

A lack of raw materials

Despite its legal status, Jiangsu Clean is finding it difficult to gain access to the raw materials. Song told China Daily that his company reclaims "50 percent" of the gutter oil produced in the city every day.

However, according to Lu Fengchao, who drives an oil tanker for Jiangsu Clean in Suzhou, the company can only reclaim 20 percent of the city's daily output of gutter oil. "The rest is seized by illegal collectors. They've got a network. Almost every day, we have confrontations with them, you know, to fight for the gutter oil. But they can gather a group of thugs with one phone call and we have no choice but leave the oil to them," he said.

Moreover, even though Jiangsu Clean is the only collector approved by the Suzhou government, some restaurant owners simply ignore the regulations. "The owners, especially the canteen managers in big factories and companies, mostly State-owned, simply refuse to provide us with the used oil because we don't have to pay them. Instead, they sell it to illegal collectors for about 4,000 yuan a ton," Lu said.

New strategy

In a bid to prevent restaurants from selling waste oil to illegal collectors, the authorities in Shanghai have drawn up a new strategy allowing oil-processing companies to collect the raw materials directly.

"Under the plan, the number of intermediate links are reduced, thus cutting out some of the collectors who sell the waste oil to illegal companies," said Gu Zhenhua, deputy director of the Shanghai Food Safety Office.

The plan is part of the city's latest move to crack down on the recycling of gutter oil and prevent it from returning to the city's dining tables. "The oil processing companies are responsible for the whole chain of collecting, transporting and processing the waste oil," said Gu.

Under the new regulation, all restaurants in the city are required to install machinery designed to prevent the waste oil from entering the city sewers. This equipment eradicates the possibility of underground gangs collecting the oil at source by separating the oil and grease from the waste water before it enters the sewerage system. The installation of the new machinery is scheduled to be completed by the end of 2012.

However, while the cities are cleaning up their acts, Zhao Feng plans to carry on working as long as he can. For him, gutter oil means survival: "It's smelly work and it's tiring, but it makes me a lot of money and does a lot of good for the city".

Write to reporters at xieyu@chinadaily.com.cn and wanghongyi@chinadaily.com.cn